Permanent jewelry is meant to be worn every day — which means choosing the right piece matters. Most people don’t realize that the decision-making part is just as important as the welding itself.
At Bonded by Gigi, we’ve helped countless first-timers and returning guests get permanent jewelry in Lake Geneva, and along the way we’ve seen a few common mistakes people worry about after the fact. The good news? These are all easy to prevent when the experience is done thoughtfully.
Here’s what people often get wrong — and how we make sure they don’t.
Mistake #1: Choosing a Fit That Isn’t Comfortable for Everyday Life
One of the biggest mistakes people make is assuming permanent jewelry should fit too tight or too loose.
In reality, permanent jewelry needs to:
-
move comfortably with you
-
feel natural throughout the day
-
work for sleeping, working, and daily activities
How We Prevent It
We always start with a test fit. Nothing is welded until you’re completely happy with how it feels and looks and it passes our test. We take our time adjusting placement and size so the piece feels right — not just in the moment, but long-term.
Mistake #2: Picking a Style That Doesn’t Match Your Lifestyle
A piece that looks cute in theory isn’t always the best choice for everyday wear.
People sometimes worry afterward about:
-
snagging
-
bulkiness
-
pieces feeling too busy
How We Prevent It
We carefully select chains that will work well for everyday life. That means avoiding chains that are too dainty to hold up to everyday wear, will tarnish easily, or are too thick to be safe. We also use connector charms only, which sit seamlessly between the chain instead of dangling — making them less likely to catch and easier to live with.
Mistake #3: Feeling Rushed Into a Decision
Permanent jewelry shouldn’t feel like a rushed purchase. When people feel pressured to choose quickly, they’re more likely to second-guess their decision later.
How We Prevent It
We keep the experience calm and unhurried. You’re encouraged to ask questions and take a moment before anything is finalized. Permanent jewelry is meant to feel exciting — not stressful.
Mistake #4: Not Understanding How Removal or Repairs Work
Some people hesitate to book permanent jewelry because they’re unsure what happens if:
-
it needs to be removed for medical reasons
-
it breaks
-
life simply requires a change
How We Prevent It
We explain upfront that permanent jewelry can be cut at the jump ring (the small round ring where it’s welded), keeping the chain intact. We also always offer free rewelds, so your jewelry can continue being part of your story without added stress.
Mistake #5: Choosing a Place That Focuses on Speed Over Experience
Permanent jewelry is as much about the experience as it is about the piece. When the process is rushed or overly transactional, it can feel intimidating — especially for first-timers.
How We Prevent It
At Bonded by Gigi, we focus on making the experience:
-
welcoming
-
comfortable
-
fun and relaxed
It’s not just about getting welded — it’s about enjoying the moment and feeling confident every step of the way.
Why Guidance Matters When Choosing Permanent Jewelry
Permanent jewelry isn’t something most people do often, so having someone guide you through the process makes a big difference. When done thoughtfully, the result is a piece that feels effortless, personal, and easy to wear every day.
That’s what we aim for every single time.
Booking Permanent Jewelry at Bonded by Gigi
We accept walk-ins whenever time allows, or you can book online if you prefer to lock in a specific time — especially helpful for weekends, groups, or visitors.
👉 Book your permanent jewelry appointment here:
https://www.bondedbygigi.com/pages/permanent-jewelry
Helpful to know if booking online:
-
Each person receiving permanent jewelry needs their own time slot
-
Deposits are applied toward your total purchase
Where to Find Us
Bonded by Gigi is located inside The Market of Lake Geneva at:
830 W Main St
Lake Geneva, WI
Whether you’re local or visiting, we’re here to make permanent jewelry feel approachable, comfortable, and genuinely enjoyable.
The Takeaway
Most permanent jewelry “mistakes” are completely avoidable when the experience is guided with care. By focusing on fit, comfort, lifestyle, and transparency, we make sure your jewelry feels just as good months from now as it does the day you get it.
If you’re looking for a thoughtful, trusted permanent jewelry experience in Lake Geneva, Bonded by Gigi is here to take care of you.